Elijah Craig Small Batch (94 proof, $25) The setup is like this: "If you've had Whiskey A then Whiskey B is" hotter, spicier, sweeter, more floral, etc. That is because I am literally going from one bourbon to the other and recording my impressions of the difference. At worst you have a bourbon that you can experiment making cocktails with, however more likely than not, youll realize that you now have a bourbon that is straightforward and easy to enjoy. Kroger Hints of cherry round out an uncomplicated but enticing nose. It implies that a 10 point jump in proof equates to a 100% increase in MSRP, from $20 to $40, which seems a bit tough to accept. On the face of it, then, this is a high-value brand that offers a taste of small batch flavors on a budget. Washington Whiskey Black Label has a thinner mouthfeel and a gentler, less concentrated spice to the mouth. 118. Sign UpYes, I would like to receive Paste's newsletter, 2023 Paste Media Group. Strength: 45% ABV/90 proof. The end result is a pleasingly sweet palate that is the highlight of the sip. Our Bottled-In-Bond Bourbon is 100 proof and follows the exacting standards of a Bottled-In-Bond product; aged for four years, distilled in one distilling season at one distillery and under U.S. government supervision. Product description. The Most Underrated Bourbons According To Bartenders: Old Grand-Dad Bonded. On the palate, this is predominantly sweet, but with just enough of a trailing, oaky finish to give it a bit of backbone and avoid seeming too youthful. The finish shows more cinnamon and is longer. Overall the design harkens to an earlier type of whiskey bottle with simple, nostalgic, and tasteful lines. Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch: is spicier on the nose, showing more cinnamon. . On the palate, the Evan Williamsfeels thinlacking in body, hits you withspice at first, that rapidly mellows out intohoney and vanilla, with just a bit of oak. Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond or White Label is a big step up. Canadian Although some version of "Since 1783" appears on every bottle of Evan Williams, whiskey historians (yes, that, Evan Williams Straight Kentucky Bourbonvs. Evan Williams 1783 Small Bath. . There are also a few other bourbons that may be available in the gift shop, such as Evan Williams 23 Years Old and Evan Williams Red Label (101 proof, 12 years old). Bottle overall is designed to influence and appearance is trying to convey an upscale bourbon. Have you had all 3? Some rights reserved. The whiskey community wasn't happy about it, and understandably so: the $15 bottle was one of the best value buys in all of bourbon. Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond. Sometimes a wallet-friendly price point and the basics are enough to earn that chance. Again, Im getting brown sugar, light corny sweetness and hints of nuttinessdefinitely less nuts than youd get in even younger Heaven Hill bourbon, like Evan Williams Black Labelalong with a pleasant array of spice, from semi-subtle rye spice to flashes of black pepper, cinnamon and candied ginger. The aroma is on the more basic side, however, it does its job just fine and adequately opens the sip. . A subtle bit of oak creeps in after that, giving way to a fairly dry, medium-length finish. Evan Williams Bottled in Bond: is sweeter on the nose with more baking spice and hints of chocolate. An additional quick hit of heat follows and that, and then swiftly ramps down and fades away, leaving you with a light residual of oak. Age: Non-Age Stated (Around 6-8 years) ABV: 45%. The Irreverent Home of Frugal Bourbon Drinkers Since 2012, Reviews: Other Whiskey (Not Bourbon or Rye), If You've Hadthe Evan Williams Edition, Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch Bourbon, 90 proof . Commonly Fine is a blog about great beers, wines and spirits at great prices. Thats a LOT of different bourbon brands from one distillery between the $10 to $30 or $40 range, especially considering that all of them are made with the same mash bill. Fruit That's because they all use the same mashbill for distillation; the differences come with the wood aging. This is presumably the same mash bill and barrels used for JW Dant and JTS Brown BiB, two other value BiB bourbons that I posted about last week, as they are also made by Heaven . Switzerland So if you've had Whiskey A, but not Whiskeys B through E, then the Whiskey A section will be the most useful to you. A lot. Evan Williams set up his distillery on the banks of the Ohio River in 1783 and is historically recognized as Kentucky's first distiller of bourbon. The Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond, meanwhile, has a 7-year age statementso doesnt that imply that these two are roughly the same age? . Evan Williams Single Barrel (86.6 proof, $30) Table Wine Evan Williams Black Label (80 proof, $13) Evan Williams Bottled-In-Bond is bright gold in color. According to the press release, the bourbon is pulled from less than 300 barrels. Sweet, sweet, sweet as most inexpensive bourbons are, but pleasant none-the-less. The BiB is also 7% higher ABV. So without further ado, I present the eighth installment of theIf Youve Hadseries. The bourbon is a 2015 vintage bottled at 119 proof (much higher than usual for Evan Williams Single Barrel), and each bottle comes with a collectible 2023 Pegasus Pin. In addition to this BiB, the other Evan Williams Bourbons are: Evan Williams Bourbon 86 proof (Black Label), Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch (90 proof), Evan Williams Single Barrel, a few flavored bourbons, a cider and an Egg Nog. Privacy Policy. Evan Williams is a brand of Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey bottled in Bardstown, Kentucky, by the Heaven Hill company. The finishes are fairly similar in length and heat. The youngest bottle I have of age stated is from 95, and the oldest is from 87. Pilsner Whisky So, it is older and stronger than the standard Evan Williams Black Label. Article [], Copyright 2023 Whisky, Whiskey & Bourbon | Trellis Framework by Mediavine, Evan Williams 1783 vs Single Barrel: Price comparison. The current portfolio of brands includes Elijah Craig, Old Fitzgerald, Rittenhouse, and - of course - Evan Williams. Napa Vanilla, caramel, a hint of gingerbread, and candied dark fruit pour forth from the glass in a balanced array sweet scents. Even compared to Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond, there is more oak in this new 1783. Evan Williams Bottled-In-Bond. One brand has hints of banana and contains 40% ABV, while the other tastes like buttered caramel and apple with 43% ABV. The finish is longer. For folks still bitter about it . 86 Evan Williams Bonded, White Label (100 proof, $16) It ranks as one of the better entry levels bourbons available at this . The finish of 1783 is more floral and mintier. Seasonal I bought Green Label from them in December for $12.99 per 750mL.). Stop by at one of our four locations or visit our website for free home delivery, in store pickup & shipping options! Evan Williams has a lighter flavor and lower proof bottling, whereas Ezra Brooks has spicier flavor and higher proof bottling. Costco Evan Williams Bottled-In-Bond, or White Label, is their 100 proof bottled in bond . Earned Double Gold Medal at the 2021 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. Sweet vanilla, oak, toasted brown sugar, and light caramel swirl together creating a pleasing soiree of sweet flavors that fills the mouth. 74. Evan Williams Bottled in Bond: is sweeter on the nose showing more vanilla and chocolate. Organic I compared it directly with Evan Williams Black,Heaven Hill BiB, andHenry McKenna BiB. Tonight we are featuring the Evan Williams family of bourbons. For years, Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch was an easy-to-overlook bourbon. Cooking Mashbill: 78% Corn, 12% Malted Barley, 10% Rye. Red Wine Evan Williams' signature as it appeared on an 18th century distillation license. Privacy Policy. Which do you prefer? Single Barrel is a five-time Whiskey of the Year award winner. No, it won't share the 10-year age statement, but . HH is targeting a different profile with the 1783 compared with the BIB. We talk about bourbon, rye, or any American whiskey here (yes, even Jack). Yet delivers nice sweet tasting notes with moderate oak to it. Except where otherwise noted, this website is licensed under aCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported license. Regardless, lets get to actually tasting whats inside this bottle. All of Heaven Hills' standard bourbon is the same mashbill - from lowly Heaven Hill black label to Elijah Craig Barrel Proof. All in all, this profile says value in a way that a big distillery can offer, and a small distillery can never really hope to match. There are a few facts worth knowing about the Evan Williams 1783: The nose issmooth and sweet, with a rich hint of vanilla, followed by cotton candy and a tad of oak. Light corn syrup, trending yellow. Its times like these that Im glad its not my job to rationalize the subtle differences between half a dozen different bourbon brands. Bardstown Bourbon Co. Evan Williams Bottled in Bond: is sweeter on the nose showing more vanilla and chocolate. Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch honors the year that Evan Williams founded Kentuckys first distillery. I'd read that it was a pretty good value bourbon and decided on a whim to pick it up. Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey lives up to its designation with a bold flavor profile and a smoothness that belies its high proof. Nose: right away, I'm reminded of sour milk. 1783 is a small batch bourbon using less than 200 barrels; which is a bit too high for a supposedly small batch. Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch - Review Color: Brownish copper On the nose: Extremely similar to the Black Label, this is balanced upon a tripod of oak, stone, and metal. The Bourbon. Last September I was in Kentucky. This bourbon might not be stellar, but one of the cheapest Single Barrels and still tastes reasonably well with some tasting notes that remind me of the Eagle Rare. Enjoy reading The Whiskey Jug? The finishes are basically identical. Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond is aged under government supervision and meeting the exact requirements for a Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon. 10. Some rights reserved. Evan Williams BiB is just one of the numerous non age-stated Heaven Hill bourbons and while its flavor profile is more traditional and somewhat one-dimensional, it still offers subtle characteristics unique to the brand and delivers them in its own unique way. Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch - Details and Tasting Notes Whiskey Details Region: Kentucky, USA Distiller: Heaven Hill Distillery Mash Bill: 75% corn, 13% rye, 12% barley Cask: new charred oak Age: NAS (6+ Years stated on site) ABV: 45% Price: $20* Ill save the detailed results of the comparison for a futureBreaking Bourbon Face Off, but in simple terms side by side, each of these bourbons does offer its own distinguishing characteristics, as subtle as they may be. How about that?! Exploring the dark depths of my liquor cabinet this weekend, I made the happy discovery that I had two similar-but-different bottles of Evan Williams Kentucky Bourbon hiding in the shadows behind a nearly empty bottle of dry vermouth and a forgotten bottle of Amaretto that I still haven't figured out how to use. I thought I was done with these posts, not because I dont like doing them, but Id done all of the ones I could think of. This bottled-in-bond bourbon is aged for a smoother, more complex flavor - world-renowned by bourbon lovers. Tasting But Evan Williams is a value brand. Go to ko-fi.com/bourbonguy to support. The main difference between Jack Daniel's vs Evan Williams Bourbon lies in their flavors, place of distillation, and alcohol content. After letting it sit for a 5-10 minutes the sour milk fades and is replaced by a sweet caramel much like bourbon 1. I can see why they could be considered duplicates in the Evan Williams line-up. Well, Evan Williams was born in Wales in 1755 and emigrated to the US in 1780. amrttEvan Williams 23; . 50% Alc/Vol (100 proof). Saison Of course, sometimes you buy something just because you want to compare it to something else. Want to read about another Evan Williams bourbon? Thomas Keller Its full flavored and assertive with a welcomed amount of heat, though I would still describe it as smooth for its proof. Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch Straight Bourbon Whiskey 45% (USA) $19.00. Double Decker Interview Evan Williams Single Barrel (2013 vintage): is very similar, though showing more floral notes, on the nose. The finishes are virtually identical. French The answer is probably right there in the question: to make 1783 a better known member of this inexpensive but high-quality bourbon brand. Murphy's For two brands with nearly identical production techniques, a slight edge goes to Ezra Brooks. Inexpensive and sturdy, this Evan Williams is great in cocktails or over ice. Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch: is spicier on the nose, showing prominent cinnamon notes. The finish follows the mouth showing more cinnamon, fruit, and floral notes. Made from a mash comprised of of 78% corn, 10% rye and 12% malted barley. The only 1783 10 year age stated bottles I have/have seen, have all been pre-fire. If anything, what this release really points out is that the Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond that was redesigned in 2019 is something of a tough sellwhy spend $40 when there are so many solid, high-value options from the same distillery at nearly half the price? While the bottle may proclaim that this whiskey is Kentucky's 1st Distiller, and pays homage to a 1783 distiller by the name of Evan Williams, in reality the current production of whiskey has no association (other than in name) with that individual and instead is produced by the Heaven Hill distilling company. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Distillery: Heaven Hill Age: 4 Years, according to the Heaven Hill website, though it is not mentioned on the specific Evan Williams site. I like these for drinking, not tasting and wouldn't hesitate if offered either during a hand of cards. Drinking to two side by side, its hard to understand why the taste difference is so large considering its supposed to be the same starting product and 1783 cant be that much older than 4 years at $28 a 1.75L. I tried a few in the thread but it was a buddy of mine who asked if I'd tried Evan Williams 1783. Food Seems like they are going for different flavor profiles with these products and have blended their barrels accordingly. Origin Wheated Bottled in Bond Bourbon . I like to travel. The resulting bourbon is one that is simplistic and enjoyable yet lacks any defining characteristics that help differentiate it from other sub-$30 bourbons such as Buffalo Trace, Wild Turkey 101, or even the companys own Elijah Craig Small Batch. . Import The EW Single Barrel is vintage-dated, meaning each bottle is marked with the vintage date it was put into oak, along with the year it was bottled and the serial number of the barrel that the spirit was extracted from. Or what about the beloved Evan Williams Bonded, which carries a 100 proof level for roughly $15? Islay Consumers like choice, or at least the appearance of choice within a fairly narrow band of optionsthis much is obvious to anyone who has ever set foot in the whiskey aisle, where a handful of major distilleries control most of the shelf space with a wide array of products, many of which tend to be only subtle deviations from each other. Black Label has less spicy heat than 1783 but has a more pronounced cinnamon flavor. Click & Collect (Mon-Fri 10am - 5pm) Free. The mouthfeel on Black Label is thinner and the finish is longer. And if so much of my travel didn't involve bourbon in some way shape or form. Like the nose, flavors of wood and oak are absent here, as sweet notes of vanilla, caramel, burnt brown sugar, and a touch of black pepper take over. Related research topic ideas. Evan Williams Green Label (80 proof) may be available regionally. This exchange seems odd for a bourbon that is composed of 6-8 year old barrels. The mash bill of corn, malted barley, rye, and wheat is sourced from farmers within a 100-mile radius. By that measure its a tremendous value for only $15. Affordable American Jim Vorel is a Paste staff writer and resident brown liquor geek. Are you planning a trip to Kentucky Distilleries? SigmanBottle is a liquor store in the Metro Atlanta area. Evan Williams Bourbon is the second best selling bourbon in the US and the world. Trader Joe's These include an embossed Evan Williams signature in the glass itself along with a wrapped top that hides the twist-off cap beneath it. 1. One of these was Evan Williams 1783. Pumpkin You must be 21 or over to enter this website. The move was prompted by the rapid growth of Evan Williams 1783, Evan Williams Bottled in Bond, and other products that draw from the same barrel inventory. I like it so much that I'd write a travel blog if it wasn't cheaper to go buy a bottle of bourbon than catch a flight to Louisville. Full flavored but still smooth, this sweet tasting BiB bourbon wont wow you, but offers enough versatility to make it a mainstay in any home bar, all for less than $20. not something I want to nose at all. You can follow him on Twitter for more drink writing. On the nose, this newly redesigned Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch smells sweetly inviting, combining some of the classic Heaven Hill bourbon nuttiness (peanut shells and hints of peanut butter) with brown sugar, cinnamon and slight gingerbread. Made from a mash comprised of of 78% corn, 10% rye and 12% malted barley. 1783 is a small batch bourbon using less than 200 barrels; which is a bit too high for a supposedly small batch. The best music, movies, TV, books, comedy and more. Europe 70. What do you think? With a nose of oak and vanilla, a palate of honey and oak, and a . Suffice to say, the 10 year age stated 1783 is on of the finest bourbons I've ever had. We are looking at the 80 proof Evan Williams Green Label (which, rumor has it, has been discontinued*), the 86 proof Black Label, the new 90 proof 1783 Small Batch, Bottled-in-Bond, and the 2013 vintage of Evan Williams Single Barrel. TASTING NOTE: "Neutral on the nose with rounded sweetness and subtle notes of citrus. Never miss another article! Evan Williams is revered as the first ever commercial distiller in Kentucky (he started in 1783). Therefore, all the bourbon in the BIB is the same age while 1783 could have some older barrels mixed (although the majority is probably a little over 4 years). Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon has the classic bourbon flavors, although with a fair amount of sweetness. Did you enjoy this post? 20. Here comes disclaimer-time: I did this in my normal double blind tasting routine where I draw a circle with an A in it, one with a B in it, one with a 1 and then one with a 2. This product sits smack-dab in the middle of a crowded lineup of bourbons from Heaven Hill, and it simultaneously illustrates the distillerys ability to craft solid bourbon with budget pricing, but also the way that the distillerys lineup may simply have become a bit too myopically specialized.